0
Views

China Drops Criminal Charges Against Captain in Baltic Anchor Dragging Case

Chinese cotnainership arriving Russia after NSR passage
NewNew Polar Bear arriving in Russia in 2023 (Global Ports)

Chinese prosecutors told a court in Hong Kong on Wednesday that they are not pursuing the criminal charges against the captain of a containership accused of damaging a gas pipeline and telecommunication cables in the Baltic in 2023. According to media reports, the captain of the containership NewNew Polar Bear is being released after pleading guilty to two minor negligence charges related to the operation of the vessel and was ordered to pay a nominal fine.

Captain Wan Wenguo, age 43, from mainland China, had been held in detention in Hong Kong since 2024 as prosecutors worked to build a case related to the damage caused by dragging the anchor of the vessel. Hearings had started in December 2024 and proceeded in the Hong Kong court as lawyers argued questions of jurisdiction and other preliminary issues. 

Prosecutors reportedly now told the court that they were unable to locate key witnesses for the criminal case, which had been due to start its trial next month. Wan had indicated he was pleading not guilty, with his lawyers asserting it was accidental.

The 15,592-dwt containership drew attention first for its voyage from China to Russia crossing the Northern Sea Route. After reaching the Baltic in October 2023, the ship was starting its return voyage when there were reports of damage to the Balticconnector natural gas pipeline and telecommunication cables running between Estonia and Finland. 

Finnish authorities launched an investigation and identified the NewNew Polarbear, which was discovered to be missing one of its anchors. They found a more than 50-mile trail across the seafloor and recovered the anchor. China, however, did not cooperate in the investigation and later said it would prosecute the captain. The damage to the undersea infrastructure was reported at more than $50 million.

In addition to the criminal charge for damaging the infrastructure, Wan was charged with two negligence counts. One is related to operating the containership without having proper anchors, and the other is for not providing daily updates to the shipping company. 

The South China Morning Post reports that lawyers for the captain asserted he told the shipping company the ship had lost an anchor and tried to source a replacement in Russia. They said the shipping company had ordered the ship to sail due to the fact its schedule was coordinated to the availability of icebreakers to complete the Northern Sea Route transit. 

The lawyers further said the captain encountered communications problems while in the Arctic. Wan admitted to not providing daily reports on position and speed to the shipping company between October 28 and November 3, 2023. 

The captain admitted to violating the two navigation rules and indicated he would pay a fine. The South China Morning Post reports the shipping company paid a fine of roughly US$200 and the captain was sentenced to pay approximately US$500. He was given until June 30, 2027, to pay the fine. He was also immediately ordered deported to the mainland, meaning it is unlikely the fine will be paid.

The damage caused by the NewNew Polar Bear raised awareness and spurred accusations of a hybrid war in the Baltic. There were several more documented cases of ships damaging infrastructure by dragging their anchors, and other false alarms. 

Finland attempted one prosecution, but a court said under international law the jurisdiction was with the registry country of the vessel or the home of the accused crewmember. An appeals court overturned the ruling and sent the case back to the court, while Finland recently convicted a captain and boatswain in another anchor-dragging case.

The Scandinavian countries and NATO have subsequently increased their patrols and monitoring of the Baltic.