22
Views

Rip and Replace or Wait? Yards Have a Third MRO Modernization Option

Naval frigate under maintenance in a floating dry dock at a shipyard

Oxalis Chief Commercial Officer Sasha Trifunac recently joined The Maritime Executive podcast to talk about what is slowing down shipyard modernization and why the answer may not be the one most yards expect.

Every availability a shipyard works is a complex puzzle of subcontractors, materials, and inspections, all under constant schedule pressure. Even within the same company, that web can look very different from yard to yard, as each is responding to the realities of what it can deliver within the yard versus what it subcontracts.

By definition, that kind of work struggles to standardize. It’s partly why tools built for other industries never fully deliver, and why so much work still runs on paper and Excel. Any technology that wants to be relevant has to embrace the iteration instead of fighting it.

Sitting on top of that is a dual tension that government and commercial fleet owners share, just for different reasons. The Navy is stretched thin and under pressure to do more within shorter availabilities. Mission readiness is critical. A ship in dry dock can’t answer the call. Readiness is won by accelerating the schedule.

Commercial owners have the same problem, just through a financial lens. Maintenance turns an earning asset into a cost event, and with higher interest rates, the capital cost for that work gets more painful. Different reasons, same urgency. Both sides need the work done, the yard modernized faster, and neither can afford to wait.

At the same time, everyone in the value chain knows that ripping out a system of record is risky, expensive, and takes a long time.

Stuck between a huge investment and a long wait

The common belief is that there are two choices: rip the system out and replace it with a new system, or wait years and delay the fix. A significant upgrade carries under-appreciated execution risk that can yield frustratingly little despite long and costly timelines.

Cutover is its own risk, with data migration and every transition point in between. This is part of why people end up as deer in headlights, afraid to stop, and stuck with aging systems and a widening digital debt.

The third option in maintenance, repair, and overhaul (MRO) is YARDOS: a new layer that brings most of the benefits of modernization forward without jeopardizing your current system of record.

Keep your ERP. Make it speak maritime.

YARDOS is not a replacement for the big ERP and scheduler platforms. Those systems are still fundamentally necessary, and the Oxalis view is to keep your ERP.

If that ERP is IFS, Oxalis is an IFS Specialized Partner and helps maritime organizations implement it. If it is something else, the advice does not change. What matters is adapting those tools to speak the language on the deck plate.

And when a tool slows someone down, they go back to paper and Excel because it’s reliable. Yards are doing the right thing when they ask whether something is practical, whether it is necessary, and whether it will help their people.

That is the standard YARDOS was built to meet, from the deck plate up. Oxalis spent a decade inside shipyards on Navy maintenance, repair, and overhaul, digitizing the forms and approvals that were still on paper, and designing the platform to run the full lifecycle from bid to closeout.

The team jokes that the CEO and VP of Product keep their steel-toed boots ready, because walking the yard alongside the supervisors and trades earned YARDOS true adoption. The result is a platform that finally pulls all the MRO data into one digital record from bid to closeout.

AI is only as good as the data underneath it

Plenty of yards are experimenting with AI and finding it is only as good as its training data and architecture. Most yard data is scattered across systems, which limits what any model can learn from it and burns far more tokens, driving up cost.

Once MRO data is elevated into one place, the training potential for a specialist AI is leaps and bounds better. Bid estimation is the first use case yards want. They store every estimate and let AI draft a bid from the parameters of the work spec.

The bigger opportunity is in live availabilities. Superintendents and project managers know the operating rules from experience, and specialist AI can capture that knowledge and help avoid delays that butterfly across the schedule. Call it a game of schedule Tetris. The specialist AI explores the scenarios and surfaces the risk to the right person before the risk escalates.

Digitize anything and the gains start at 10%

At the Fleet Maintenance & Modernization Symposium (FMMS) this fall, a yard leader told Oxalis that the second they digitize anything, they see an immediate 10% benefit. That number says a lot about the untapped potential sitting in these yards.

The data has been so difficult to capture and consolidate that most yards struggle to establish a baseline. Once that data is in one place and the intelligence is built on top of it, shortening availabilities and tightening resource coordination becomes a reality.

Oxalis will be demoing YARDOS at the International WorkBoat Show in New Orleans, December 2 to 4 at booth 3660, for commercial fleet owners, government fleet owners, and the yards that serve them. Schedule a demo.

This message is sponsored by Oxalis.

The opinions expressed herein are the author's and not necessarily those of The Maritime Executive.