Cruise Ship Detained and Cited as Brazilian Startup Struggles
A startup operation hoping to launch a new cruise operation in Brazil is reporting difficulties just days after it began operations. The Spanish cruise line Corazul had paused operations, which is leading to a further dispute with its travel agency in Brazil, while the authorities also cited the ship for deficiencies.
Hopes were high in Brazil for a record cruise season, in part with the launch of Corazul and the addition of its cruise ship Buenavista. The ship’s arrival at the Port of Santos at the end of October drew wide attention, but it quickly turned to problems.
Corazul originally announced plans to launch its operations over the summer from Spain but cited problems completing the charter and a late start on the season. It finally took delivery of the ship in September from the Chinese owners and made a quick shipyard visit in Hong Kong in preparation for the start of service from Brazil.
The company formed a marketing relationship with China’s Astro Ocean, which has operated the cruise ship for the past few years as the Piano Land in the Chinese market. As one of the first modern cruise ships built by Germany’s Meyer Werft, the 69,000 gross ton ship sailed from 1995 to 2019 as P&O Cruises’ Oriana. The ship has accommodations for approximately 2,000 passengers and currently operates with a crew of approximately 600.
Renamed Buenavista, comments quickly shifted to the rust-stained exterior when the ship reached Santos in late October. Reports blamed it on the long ocean crossing from Hong Kong. The ship had also been laid up since June off Hong Kong before the handover.
The line launched mini-preview cruises days after the ship reached Brazil, and reports came quickly back of poor operations. Two of the ship’s swimming pools were closed, and the casino was not operating. There were reports of malfunctioning plumbing, poor service, and a lack of crew. Making the situation worse, Corazul had invited many members of the travel community to sample the ship on the preview cruises.
After just two short voyages, Corazul said it would pause operations to complete upgrades on the ship to prepare for the high season in Brazil. The company promised financial refunds to the affected passengers.
Tour operator R11 had a four-year exclusive distribution agreement with Corazul. It took the company to court, claiming it was owed more than US$1.1 million in fees and commissions but also admitted it was holding US$925,000 in receipts from prospective passengers. Under the terms of the agreement, the company only pays the cruise line for the passengers when the cruise begins.
The judge in Brazil found in favor of the tour operator and detained the ship at the Port of Santos as of November 13. Corazul was ordered to post approximately $300,000 plus costs for the release of the ship. R11 was also given 30 days to pursue its claim, or it will be voided.
Brazilian authorities also ordered an inspection of the ship, and reports indicate they cited a list of deficiencies. They included work rule violations for the crew and other working condition issues. They also cited issues such as a lack of first aid supplies, which Corazul said it would immediately correct.
that matters most
Get the latest maritime news delivered to your inbox daily.
Corazul had planned to resume sailing on November 13. It said it filed an immediate appeal to the detention order but delayed the resumption of cruising until November 30. It still expects to resume cruises at the end of the month. It said the ship required additional work to return it to Western standards after having operated in China for seven years. They promised to improve the on-board passenger experience while saying their focus is on the safety of the passengers and crew.
Plans called for Corazul to continue to cruise from Brazil at least until April. The company scheduled the ship to move to Spain for the summer months, although it said it would consider year-round service from Brazil based on the strength of the market.