0
Views

Panama Cites “Irregularities” in Criminal Complaint Over Port Concession

Panama Cristobal container terminal
Panama is now pursuing criminal charges related to the extension of the port concession to the subsidiary of CK Hutchison

The Comptroller General of Panama has raised new issues in the ongoing battle over the port concession held for nearly 30 years by a subsidiary of Hong Kong-based CK Hutchison. After an audit of the concession, the Comptroller General reports that it submitted a criminal complaint to the Public Prosecutor’s Office for further investigation.

Officials in Panama have cited concerns over the concession, which was annulled by the Panama courts earlier this year. After Panama seized the port operations from the Panama Ports Company, a subsidiary of CK Hutchison, the company started a series of arbitration claims against Panama. It also accused Panama of illegally taking control of property and proprietary information.

The Comptroller General’s Office is now reporting that it audited 10 years of the contract with the Panama Ports Company and referred the case to the prosecutors based on the financial and compliance audit. It reviewed the full concession dating back to 1997 but focused on the period between 2014 and 2024.

The criminal referral reportedly focused on the individuals who participated in the drafting and approving of the extension of the concession in 2021 for an additional 25 years. The complaint is reportedly directed at the members of the board of the Panama Maritime Authority between 2014 and 2023, the general administrators of the Authority, and the Panama Ports Company. The positions at the Authority were political appointments made by the prior president and administration. Panama elected a new president in May 2024.

CK Hutchison had previously refuted claims from Panama that it had not made the required payments under its concession. The company cites large financial investments made into the operations while asserting it honored the terms of the contract.

Chinese officials have repeatedly asserted that the dispute was politically motivated and under pressure from the Trump administration. They said the cancelation of the contract called into question investments in Panama and, while never confirming the actions, took a series of retaliatory actions. Panama was accused of increased inspections and detentions of Panama-flagged ships calling at Chinese ports and of discouraging Chinese companies from operations and investments in Panama.

The Prosecutor’s Office said it would be reviewing the documents provided by the Comptroller General. 

Panama assigned the operations of the port terminals in Balboa and Cristobal to Maersk’s APM Terminals and to MSC’s Terminal Investments (TiL). Panama has declared its intention to rebid the two concessions independently as well as to pursue the development of competing terminals in the two ports at each terminus of the Panama Canal. It recently said it would pre-qualify, by the end of this year, the companies to bid for the two new terminals, which will be developed in Corozal, on the Pacific, and Telfers, on the Atlantic.