0
Views

When a Ship Is Arrested or Detained, Should Its Crew Pay the Price?

Phil Schifflin of the Seamen’s Church Institute in a hard hat and safety vest at Port Newark
Phil Schifflin, Esq., visiting seafarers in Port Newark, NJ (David Rider / Seamen’s Church Institute)

When a commercial vessel was arrested in a U.S. port, the seafarers aboard suddenly found themselves subject to unexpected restrictions. Guards were stationed aboard to prevent them from leaving, and the entire crew was required to muster every four hours so everyone could be accounted for.

For seafarers already facing uncertainty about their vessel’s future, the requirement created another hardship: repeated interruptions to their rest, making it difficult to obtain adequate sleep. There was no indication of when the restrictions might be relaxed.

Yet the vessel had been arrested in connection with a commercial dispute. The crew had not been arrested, nor was the vessel detained as part of a criminal investigation.

The situation raises an important question: When a vessel is subject to legal proceedings, what restrictions on its crew are actually justified?

The answer begins with a distinction sometimes overlooked in maritime operations: arresting a vessel is not the same as detaining it, and neither action automatically means that the people aboard should be treated as though they are personally under arrest.

Under U.S. maritime law, a vessel may be arrested pursuant to a court order, generally to secure a maritime claim against the vessel or its owner. Such claims may involve unpaid crew wages, salvage, collision damage, certain unpaid supplies or services, or a ship mortgage.

One distinctive feature of maritime law is that, under certain circumstances, a vessel can be proceeded against in rem, meaning the legal action is directed against the vessel itself. A federal court may issue a warrant for the vessel’s arrest, generally executed by the U.S. Marshals Service.

The arrest places the vessel under the court’s control while the underlying claim is addressed. The vessel cannot leave the jurisdiction without authorization, but its arrest does not mean the crew members have been arrested or are suspected of wrongdoing.

A vessel detention, by comparison, generally involves an administrative or regulatory action taken by the U.S. Coast Guard or another government agency. Detentions may arise from safety deficiencies, regulatory violations, or criminal investigations.

The distinction is more than terminology. The legal authority and purpose of an arrest or detention can differ significantly, as can the measures reasonably necessary to enforce them.

For example, when a vessel is detained in connection with a criminal investigation, there may be legitimate reasons to monitor crew movements closely, particularly if authorities are concerned about individuals leaving without authorization or interfering with an investigation. Those same considerations do not necessarily apply when a vessel is arrested to secure a commercial maritime claim.

A vessel arrested because of an unpaid debt or other civil dispute must remain under the court’s control. But that requirement does not, by itself, establish that its crew presents a security risk or that extraordinary restrictions on their movements and daily routines are necessary.

Other legal or immigration requirements may still affect whether crew members can go ashore. Restrictions affecting seafarers should reflect the circumstances and applicable legal authority, rather than being imposed simply because the vessel has been arrested.

In the case described earlier, the four-hour muster requirement raised precisely these concerns.

While maintaining control over an arrested vessel is a legitimate responsibility, the circumstances did not appear to warrant such frequent monitoring of the crew. The vessel was involved in a commercial dispute, and based on the information available, there was no apparent reason to believe the seafarers presented a particular risk.

When the Seamen’s Church Institute’s Center for Mariner Advocacy (CMA) learned of the situation, it arranged for a local chaplain to visit the vessel and provide practical assistance to crew members who could not go ashore. CMA also contacted the local International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITF) inspector, who had established relationships with the government officials involved.

Through those connections, concerns were raised about the distinction between the vessel’s arrest and a detention, and whether the restrictions imposed on the crew were warranted.

After these discussions, the four-hour muster requirement was relaxed, giving the crew more opportunity for uninterrupted rest. The outcome was straightforward, but the underlying issue deserves broader attention. A legal action against a vessel resulted in restrictions affecting the daily lives and well-being of people who were not parties to the dispute.

Vessel arrests and detentions are legitimate mechanisms within maritime law. Authorities must be able to secure vessels, enforce regulations, and carry out investigations. But those responsibilities should not obscure the difference between the legal status of a ship and that of the people living and working aboard it.

Seafarers can find themselves caught in commercial disputes, financial difficulties, regulatory actions, and other circumstances they neither created nor control. The consequences may affect their employment, freedom of movement, access to essential services, and well-being.

But courts, enforcement authorities, shipowners, and other stakeholders should ensure that restrictions imposed on seafarers are justified by the circumstances, consistent with applicable law, and mindful of their welfare, including adequate rest and access to essential services.

The legal necessity of arresting or detaining a vessel should not automatically justify restricting the rights and freedoms of those aboard. A ship may be the subject of legal proceedings, but its crew should not be treated as though they are, too.

Philip C. Schifflin, Jr., Esq. is the Director of the Center for Mariner Advocacy at the Seamen’s Church Institute.

The opinions expressed herein are the author's and not necessarily those of The Maritime Executive.